How should a group decide where to meet?
The fair way to choose where to meet is to compare everyone's real travel time, not to find a point on the map. Pick the place that keeps the average journey short while holding the longest trip close to the shortest, so no single person carries the meeting. The geographic midpoint ignores roads, transit lines and who actually travels furthest.
Fair is a measurement, not an opinion
Most group plans die in the gap between “let’s meet up” and “where”. The reason is rarely the venue - it is that everyone is quietly comparing how far they would have to travel, and one person always knows they are getting the long end. Choosing well is not about taste. It is about making the travel even enough that nobody feels they are subsidising the meeting.
The two numbers that decide it
Two things tell you whether a place is fair. The first is the average journey time across the group - the obvious one. The second, and the one people skip, is the spread: the gap between the longest and the shortest trip. A spot can have a great average and still be unfair, because four people close by pull the average down while the fifth does forty-five minutes. The spread is what exposes that; the average never will.
Weight the two together and the fair place is the one that is quick on average and keeps everyone within a few minutes of each other. A bar that is fifteen minutes for three people and forty-five for the fourth loses to one that is twenty for everybody.
Why the map midpoint misleads
The instinct is to find the point in the middle. But a midpoint on a map assumes straight lines and identical travel, and cities are neither. Roads bend, transit runs on some corridors and not others, and one person cycles while another is on a train. The honest midpoint is measured in minutes on the mode each person actually uses - which is exactly what togather does, returning real venues where the group’s travel is closest to even, every person’s time shown beside the answer.
Agree on the measure first, then let the calculation pick the place.
How togather works it out
Start from travel time, not distance
Distance on a map is not what anyone experiences; a spot two miles away can be ten minutes or fifty depending on the line. Compare journeys in minutes, on the mode each person travels by.
Measure the spread, not just the average
The average hides who is inconvenienced. The gap between the longest and the shortest journey is the number that tells you whether a place is fair or whether one person is quietly carrying it.
Decide the area before anyone names a venue
Settle the fair area first, then pick from real places there. Letting the loudest person name a bar and reverse-justifying it is how the quiet person ends up with the long trip every time.
Questions
- How should a group decide where to meet?
- Compare everyone's real travel time and choose the place that keeps the average short and the longest trip close to the shortest. That is a different question from where the map midpoint falls, and it usually has a different answer.
- Why is the geographic midpoint a bad meeting point?
- Because it assumes straight lines and identical travel. The point halfway on a map can sit off every transit line and leave the person on the slow route with the longest trip, even though the map calls it central.
- What makes a meeting spot fair?
- A short average journey for the group and a small gap between the longest and shortest trip, counted as heavily as the average. A place that is quick for most but forty minutes for one person is not fair, however good the average looks.
- How do you decide where to meet without arguing?
- Agree on the measure before the venue. Once everyone accepts that the fairest spot is the one with the shortest average and the smallest spread, the answer is a calculation rather than a negotiation, and nobody has to concede.
Also worth reading
Settle it in about a minute
Add everyone’s starting point, pick how each person travels, and send the result to the group. No download, no sign-up.
Find your meeting point